Have you ever received news so devastating that your knees simply buckled beneath you?
Not because you decided to sit down. Not because you felt dizzy. Not because you were about to faint. But because, for one extraordinary moment, your body seemed incapable of holding you upright.
I have.
And recently, while listening to Bondi Terror by Sharri Markson & Alex Ryvchin, an account of devastating violence and the human lives affected by it, I heard descriptions of people receiving news that someone they loved had died.
Their knees buckled.
They collapsed.
And I recognised that response immediately.
It made me wonder: What actually happens inside the human body when an emotion becomes so overwhelming that our muscles seemingly surrender?
Because here’s the fascinating thing. We like to think that our minds control our bodies. But perhaps that relationship is far more complex than we’ve been led to believe.
Your body doesn’t wait for your permission
When devastating news arrives, the brain doesn’t simply process the information intellectually, decide it’s upsetting, and then instruct the body to respond. The response can begin before we have consciously made sense of what we’ve heard.
Sensory information is processed through interconnected networks involving the thalamus, amygdala, insula, anterior cingulate cortex, hypothalamus and prefrontal cortex.
These regions help us recognise significance, detect threats, interpret bodily sensations, regulate emotion and coordinate physiological responses.
And they don’t operate independently.
They are in constant communication with the autonomic nervous system, cardiovascular system, endocrine system and the neural circuits responsible for movement and posture. When we encounter something profoundly distressing, these networks can rapidly alter our breathing, heart rate, vascular tone, attention and muscle activity.
Sometimes this produces a recognisable vasovagal response, with a fall in blood pressure, sometimes accompanied by a slowing heart rate.
But not every emotionally triggered collapse is a faint.
In some people, awareness remains intact. There may be no dizziness, no loss of consciousness, no obvious warning. Just a sudden loss of the ability to remain standing.
The precise mechanisms of these episodes aren’t always clear. Acute emotional shock may involve changes in autonomic regulation, motor control, postural stability or functional neurological responses.
What we cannot say is that every episode of buckling knees represents one particular neurological reflex. But what we can say is this:
Our emotional experiences can produce immediate, involuntary changes in physical function. And that is extraordinary.
The neuroscience of overwhelm
Our brains are prediction-making machines. Every moment, they use incoming sensory information, past experiences and internal bodily signals to anticipate what is happening and what might happen next.
Most of the time, this occurs so seamlessly that we barely notice it. Then something happens that our internal model of the world cannot easily accommodate.
Someone we love has died.
A diagnosis changes everything.
A relationship ends unexpectedly.
A reality we believed to be stable is suddenly shattered.
The brain must reconcile what it expected with information that fundamentally contradicts it.
Meanwhile, systems involved in threat detection, attention, emotion and autonomic regulation are responding to the significance of that news.
That strange fog people describe after traumatic information?
The disbelief?
The feeling of being physically present but mentally unable to comprehend what’s happening?
These experiences can reflect acute changes in attention, cognitive processing and stress physiology. Some people also experience dissociative symptoms, including a sense of detachment or unreality.
It is not necessarily a conscious choice to disconnect. Nor does it mean the brain has literally switched off. It is a complex response to overwhelming circumstances. And sometimes the body expresses that overwhelm long before language can articulate it.
Your brain is not just in your head
Here’s where things become particularly interesting.
We often speak about the brain and body as though they’re separate entities. We talk about mental health and physical health. Emotional pain and physical pain. Psychological responses and physiological responses.
As though these experiences occupy entirely different biological territories. But the nervous system doesn’t recognise these neat divisions.
Take interoception, for example.
Interoception is our ability to sense and interpret what’s happening inside our bodies.
Our heartbeat.
Our breathing.
Hunger.
Temperature.
Visceral sensations.
The subtle physiological changes that accompany emotions.
The insular cortex is particularly important in integrating many of these internal signals.
What we experience as anxiety, anticipation, fear, excitement or emotional distress is influenced by the brain’s interpretation of bodily signals alongside our thoughts, memories and circumstances.
A racing heart can be experienced as terror. Or excitement.
The physiological sensation may be similar, but its meaning depends on context.
And the relationship works in both directions.
Our emotional state influences bodily function. Our bodily state influences emotional experience. We don’t simply have emotions in our minds and symptoms in our bodies. We experience emotions through an integrated living system.
The body remembers, but not quite how social media tells us
You’ve probably heard the expression, “The body keeps the score.”
It’s a powerful phrase.
And there’s meaningful science behind the relationship between experiences, memory, stress and physical responses. But we need to be careful with what it implies.
Trauma isn’t necessarily stored as a discrete memory inside a muscle, fascia or organ.
Rather, experiences can influence the way our nervous system learns, predicts, interprets sensations and responds to perceived threat. Through processes involving memory, conditioning, autonomic regulation and neuroplasticity, our bodies can develop patterns of response shaped by previous experiences.
A particular smell might trigger nausea.
A tone of voice might produce an immediate tightening in the chest.
A familiar environment might evoke calm.
Or apprehension.
Sometimes these responses occur before we consciously recognise the association. This is where neuroscience, biopsychology and our understanding of the body’s responses to emotional experiences become particularly fascinating.
When emotion meets movement
One area I’ve found particularly fascinating over the decades is the use of muscle monitoring within applied and specialised kinesiology. Having experienced this approach personally, I’ve found it a valuable modality for exploring the relationship between emotional experiences, bodily responses and self-awareness.
The premise is intriguing: that changes in muscle responses may provide feedback during the exploration of physical or emotional stress.
We know from neuroscience that emotion, attention, expectation and stress can influence motor activity and muscle recruitment. Our nervous system is constantly integrating information from both our internal and external environments.
Think about the difference between how you move when you’re relaxed and confident versus frightened and hypervigilant.
Your shoulders.
Your jaw.
Your breathing.
Your gait.
Your whole physical presence changes. These changes are real aspects of physiology.
Does that mean muscle testing can accurately identify specific emotional conflicts, nutritional deficiencies or hidden disease?
The scientific evidence has not established that.
And although muscle monitoring is described as a form of biofeedback within some kinesiology practices, it isn’t equivalent to validated physiological biofeedback techniques that directly measure signals such as muscle electrical activity, heart rate or skin temperature.
But I don’t believe we need to dismiss someone’s meaningful therapeutic experience simply because we haven’t established precisely why it occurred.
There is a difference between acknowledging a person’s experience and claiming that every explanation offered for that experience is scientifically proven. For me, kinesiology has been another invitation to explore the extraordinary relationship between our physical and emotional worlds.
And perhaps the most important lesson is that we remain curious, open to investigation and willing to question our assumptions, whichever side of the conversation we’re on. Because the relationship between emotion and movement is undeniable, even when our understanding of particular therapeutic modalities is still evolving.
And this brings me to something I’ve spent nearly two decades witnessing.
Birth.
Now let’s take this into the birth room
If there’s one place where the relationship between brain, body, emotion and environment becomes impossible to ignore, it’s childbirth. Because labour isn’t simply a mechanical process involving a uterus, cervix and baby.
It’s a complex neuroendocrine, physiological, psychological and social experience.
Oxytocin, prostaglandins, catecholamines, endogenous opioids, inflammatory signalling and multiple neural pathways all contribute to the extraordinary process of birth. And these systems don’t operate in isolation from a woman’s experience.
Consider what happens when a labouring woman feels frightened.
Perhaps someone enters the room abruptly.
Perhaps she’s told her labour isn’t progressing quickly enough.
Perhaps a conversation occurs over her body rather than with her.
Perhaps an examination is performed without adequate explanation or genuine consent.
Her nervous system may interpret these experiences as threatening. Her sympathetic nervous system may become more active. Heart rate, breathing, muscle tension and attention may change. Stress hormones and catecholamines may fluctuate. Her perception of pain may intensify. And her ability to feel safe, connected and in control may diminish.
None of this requires a conscious decision.
Her body is responding to the circumstances in which she finds herself.
There is evidence that severe stress can influence reproductive neuroendocrine signalling and uterine physiology. However, human labour is complex, and we cannot assume that every frightening interaction directly inhibits oxytocin or stops cervical dilatation.
Nor should we tell women that labour stalled because they were frightened, insufficiently relaxed or emotionally blocked.
That would turn an important physiological insight into yet another burden for women to carry.
A woman is not responsible for making her labour progress by thinking the right thoughts. But the environment we create around her matters.
Enormously.
Safety is more than the absence of danger
In maternity care, we frequently discuss safety in terms of clinical outcomes.
Maternal observations.
Monitoring babies’ wellbeing.
Blood loss.
Infection.
Neonatal wellbeing.
All critically important. But there’s another dimension of safety that deserves equal attention.
The experience of being safe. Of being heard. Of having agency. Of knowing that the people caring for you will communicate respectfully, seek consent, respond to your concerns and act competently when something changes.
A woman can be in a clinically well-equipped environment and still feel profoundly threatened. Equally, she can face a genuine clinical complication while feeling supported, informed and emotionally secure.
These aren’t contradictions. They reflect different dimensions of safety.
And both matter.
Trauma-informed maternity care isn’t about removing all discomfort or guaranteeing a particular birth experience. It’s about recognising that our words, actions, environments and relationships can influence the way a woman’s nervous system experiences care.
It means explaining before touching.
Asking rather than assuming.
Allowing time where clinically appropriate.
Being honest without being frightening.
Recognising that a woman’s previous experiences may shape her present responses.
And understanding that the person in front of us is not simply a uterus with a cervix attached.
She is an entire human being.
The extraordinary influence of another human being
One of the most fascinating aspects of human physiology is that we regulate ourselves partly through our relationships with others. This is often called co-regulation.
Think about a distressed child who settles when held by someone they trust.
Or the way your breathing changes when someone speaks gently and reassuringly during a frightening experience.
Or how a familiar voice can make an unfamiliar environment feel less threatening.
Human beings are profoundly social creatures.
Our nervous systems are responsive to facial expressions, vocal tone, touch, familiarity and interpersonal behaviour. These cues can influence perceived safety, emotional regulation and physiological arousal.
The evidence doesn’t support reducing every interaction to a simplistic vagal nerve switch or a universal nervous-system state. But it does support the broader principle that supportive human connection can influence our stress responses.
And in birth, that is incredibly relevant.
A midwife’s presence isn’t just about monitoring observations and documenting progress.
It’s also about relationship.
Continuity.
Familiarity.
The confidence that someone knows you.
Someone understands what matters to you.
Someone can recognise when you need reassurance, when you need information, when you need space, and when you need decisive clinical action.
This is one of the reasons I believe continuity of midwifery care is so valuable.
Not because a familiar midwife can magically make every birth straightforward. But because a trusting relationship can help women navigate one of life’s most physically and emotionally intense experiences. And importantly, the benefits of continuity of midwifery care extend beyond theory.
Research has associated midwife continuity models with improvements in several maternal and birth outcomes, although the mechanisms are multifactorial. Sometimes the most powerful thing we bring into a birth room isn’t something in our equipment bag.
It’s the relationship we’ve built.
When the body speaks, are we listening?
I keep coming back to that image. A human being receives devastating news.
Their knees buckle.
Their body momentarily cannot hold them upright.
Not because they have decided to collapse.
Not because they are weak.
But because something has happened within their integrated neurological, physiological and emotional world that has profoundly altered their physical response.
We may not be able to identify the exact mechanism in every individual case. But we can recognise the significance. And perhaps this is where our understanding of humanity needs to evolve.
We have become remarkably sophisticated at measuring individual components of the human body.
Blood pressure.
Heart rate.
Hormones.
Muscle activity.
Neural electrical signals.
We can image the brain, measure uterine contractions and observe physiological changes in extraordinary detail.
Yet sometimes we still struggle to see the human being as a whole.
We separate the psychological from the physical. We dismiss symptoms when investigations are normal. We underestimate the effect of words, relationships and environments.
And in maternity care, we sometimes become so focused on the mechanics of birth that we forget the woman experiencing it.
The brain isn’t separate from the body.
The mind isn’t an independent operator sitting somewhere inside the skull.
Our conscious experience emerges from the activity of a living nervous system, continuously interacting with the rest of the body and the world around us.
Our emotions are embodied. Our relationships are biological experiences. Our environments influence our physiology.
And birth is perhaps one of the most extraordinary demonstrations of all three.
So the next time someone says, “It’s all in your head,” perhaps we need to challenge the premise. Because what’s happening in your head is happening in your body. And what’s happening in your body is influencing your brain.
Not as two separate entities. But as one extraordinary, interconnected human being.
Perhaps the question isn’t why our bodies respond so powerfully to our emotions. Perhaps the question is why we ever imagined they wouldn’t.
⸻
Clinical note: Sudden collapse or loss of leg strength should not automatically be attributed to emotion. Syncope, neurological events and other medical causes may require assessment. The physiology of emotional collapse is varied and remains incompletely understood.
Meet Rachel - The Integrated Midwife
Rachel is a midwife passionate about bringing together evidence-based care, holistic wisdom and a deeper understanding of the journey into motherhood. Through The Integrated Midwife, she supports women to feel informed, empowered and connected to themselves throughout pregnancy, birth and beyond.
Discover more at The Integrated Midwife



